Game UX vs Game Design: What’s the Difference?

Game Design focuses on the mechanics, rules and systems that shape the player experience. Game UX focuses on how clearly players understand and interact with those systems. The roles overlap in areas such as controls, tutorials, progression, accessibility and player feedback.

Hero bild med Brian Bartram Expert Insigt om UX och Game Design

Published on

Expert contributor

This article is based on an interview with Brian.

“Game Design tends to focus on the systems and how they interact, whereas Game UX tends to focus on how the player understands those systems.”

Brian Bartram
Game Director and Contract Instructor at Futuregames Malmö

What does a Game UX Designer do? 

Game UX and Game Design both aim to create an enjoyable experience for the player, but they approach that goal from different perspectives. 

Game Design focuses primarily on the game’s mechanics, rules and systems, and how these create challenges, pacing and emotions. Game UX focuses on how clearly players understand and interact with those systems. 

“A great game needs both,” says Brian Bartram, Game Director at indie studio Something Dreadful and Contract Instructor in Game Design at Futuregames Malmö. 

With more than 20 years of experience in game design, Brian has worked at studios including Massive Entertainment, Ubisoft San Francisco, Maxis, BioWare, Visceral Games and Pandemic Studios. His credits include projects such as Avatar: Frontiers of Pandora, Dead Space 3 and SimCity. 

UX stands for User Experience. In game development, a Game UX Designer focuses on how easily players can understand the game, learn its controls and recognise why it responds in a particular way. 

The role involves identifying moments where players experience unnecessary confusion or friction. This requires close observation of how people actually play. 

A Game UX Designer may investigate questions such as: 

  • Does the player understand what to do next? 
  • Is it clear which button performs an action? 
  • Can the player recognise when an enemy has detected them? 
  • Is important information easy to find and understand? 
  • Can players with different accessibility needs interact with the game? 
  • Does the game provide clear and useful feedback? 

Game UX Designers often collaborate with Game Designers, UI Artists, Sound Designers, VFX Artists, Programmers and other members of the development team. Their task is to help the game communicate clearly without compromising its visual identity, atmosphere or sense of immersion. 

What does a Game Designer do? 

Game Designers focus on the mechanics, rules and systems that shape the player’s experience. 

They consider what the player can do, how the game responds and which emotions the experience should create. Depending on their specialisation, they may work with combat, progression, levels, narrative, controls, economies or other systems. 

“The Game Designer’s focus is on the emotional goals for the game and how the mechanics can reach those goals,” Brian explains. 

For example, a Game Designer may decide how an enemy detects the player, how difficult an encounter should be or how an upgrade changes the player’s abilities. 

The Game UX Designer then considers whether the player can understand those systems and make informed decisions while playing. 

Where do Game UX and Game Design overlap? 

The roles commonly overlap in areas such as: 

  • Player controls 
  • Tutorials and onboarding 
  • Progression and upgrades 
  • UI and feedback 
  • Accessibility 
  • Player decision-making 
  • Playtesting and iteration 

The two perspectives must work together. It is not enough for a mechanic to be interesting if the player cannot understand it. Similarly, a system that is easy to use still needs meaningful rules, choices and challenges. 

This collaboration helps players make both immediate and strategic decisions. 

An immediate decision might be: An enemy is about to attack. When should I dodge, and which button should I press? 

A strategic decision might be: Which upgrade should I choose to make my character more effective? 

Game Design creates the rules and consequences behind these decisions. Game UX helps ensure that the information needed to make them is clear. 

A practical example from Avatar: Frontiers of Pandora 

Brian experienced this collaboration while working as Lead Game Designer on Avatar: Frontiers of Pandora at Massive Entertainment. 

He was responsible for the combat experience, particularly the behaviour of non-player characters during combat. Stealth was important to creating the feeling of playing as a Na’vi fighting the RDA. 

The Game Designers focused on how enemies would detect the player and how they would respond. This included their senses, awareness and reactions. 

The UX Designer approached the same feature from the player’s perspective: 

  • How does the player recognise that an enemy is becoming suspicious? 
  • How do the UI, music and sound effects communicate increasing awareness? 
  • Does the player have enough information to avoid detection? 
  • Is it clear when the player should hide, move or attack? 

The Game Design and Game UX perspectives were, as Brian describes them, “two sides of the same coin”. 

How do Game UX Designers test the player experience? 

Playtesting is one of the most important tools in Game UX. 

The process often begins with a hypothesis about how something should be communicated to the player. The team then creates a prototype, tests it and observes whether players respond as expected. 

A prototype might be: 

  • A paper sketch 
  • A visual mock-up 
  • A clickable interface 
  • A simple digital prototype 
  • A feature implemented in the game engine 

Early tests may involve members of the development team. However, testing with people outside the team eventually becomes essential. Developers already understand how the game works, while new players reveal instructions, interactions and assumptions that are not as clear as the team believed. 

Testing early is also important because late changes can be expensive and difficult to implement. 

While working on Dead Space 3, Brian prototyped the weapon-crafting system first on paper and later in Adobe Flash. This allowed the team to explore different combinations before deciding how many weapon parts were needed. It also helped them improve the UI layout so that the system was both understandable and enjoyable to use. 

Is Game UX the same as UI design? 

No. UI, or User Interface, is an important part of Game UX, but the two terms are not interchangeable. 

A common misconception comes from seeing job titles such as “UI/UX Designer”. This can create the impression that Game UX is limited to menus, buttons and on-screen information. 

Game UX also includes the many ways a game communicates with the player, such as: 

  • Controller vibration 
  • Camera movement 
  • Sound effects 
  • Music 
  • Visual effects 
  • Lighting 
  • Animation 
  • Environmental cues 
  • Character reactions 

Some games rely heavily on traditional interfaces. Brian points to SimCity as an example where the UI carries a large amount of information. 

Other games minimise conventional interfaces to preserve immersion. Dead Space, for example, is known for using diegetic UI, where information is presented within the game world rather than through a separate overlay. 

In these games, Game UX extends far beyond menus and interface graphics. 

Which skills are important in Game UX? 

Analytical thinking and problem-solving are central to the role. Game UX Designers must observe player behaviour, identify why a problem occurs and develop several possible solutions. 

Important skills and knowledge include: 

  • User research and playtesting 
  • Rapid prototyping 
  • Interaction design 
  • Game Design fundamentals 
  • Cognitive psychology 
  • Information hierarchy 
  • Visual communication 
  • Accessibility 
  • Collaboration and communication 

The ability to test rough ideas quickly is particularly valuable. A simple paper prototype can reveal important problems before the development team spends time and money building the complete feature. 

Understanding accessibility is also essential. Games have a diverse audience, and thoughtful accessibility choices can allow more people to enjoy the experience. 

Should you choose Game UX or Game Design? 

Game Design may suit you if you enjoy: 

  • Inventing mechanics and systems 
  • Adjusting rules and numbers 
  • Creating challenges 
  • Shaping progression and pacing 
  • Exploring how systems produce emotions 

Game UX may suit you if you enjoy: 

  • Analysing human behaviour 
  • Conducting research and playtests 
  • Organising complex information 
  • Removing unnecessary friction 
  • Making interactions clear and accessible 

In practice, the disciplines are closely connected. Strong development teams create a continuous loop between Game Design, Game UX, prototyping and player feedback. 

How can education prepare you for Game UX? 

According to Brian, effective Game UX Designers often combine knowledge of Game Design, cognitive psychology and professional production pipelines. 

They need practical experience of building prototypes, testing them with players and improving them based on what they observe. They must also be able to communicate and collaborate with Art, Animation, Audio, Programming, Production and QA. 

Clear documentation is another valuable skill. On SimCity, Brian worked with a method called the “One-Page Design Document”, introduced by Lead Designer Stone Librande. It allowed the team to communicate and develop ideas in a concise, highly visual format. 

The Game and UX Designer programme at Futuregames Malmö combines user research, game psychology, accessibility, prototyping, programming and multidisciplinary game projects. Students learn to investigate player needs and turn their findings into tested experiences. 

Brian’s advice for aspiring Game UX Designers 

“Never stop learning,” Brian says. 

Game UX continues to evolve, and every game brings different players, challenges and opportunities. Curiosity, adaptability and a willingness to share knowledge are therefore important qualities. 

Game development is also highly collaborative. 

“Game development is best when you see it as a co-op game. Come prepared to collaborate, be kind and supportive to your teammates, and expect to have a rollercoaster ride of emotions along the way.” 

For Brian, the reward is reaching the end of that process together and launching something special with a team that values everyone’s contribution. 

About Brian Bartram 

Brian Bartram is Game Director at the indie studio Something Dreadful and a Contract Instructor in Game Design at Futuregames Malmö. 

He has more than 20 years of experience in game development, with previous roles including Game Director at Flashbulb Games, Lead Game Designer at Massive Entertainment and senior design positions at Ubisoft San Francisco, Maxis, BioWare, Visceral Games and Pandemic Studios. 


More to Discover

Stay up-to-date with the latest stories, insights, and highlights from Futuregames. See what’s in the spotlight and dive into our world of game development and tech.